Was Princess Gwenllian an Author?
Credit: Image Pixabay - Image by Enrique
Was Princess Gwenllian an Author?
The Mabinogion, a collection of medieval Welsh tales, has long been celebrated as one of the cornerstones of Welsh mythology. They are very old writings found in the White Book of Rhydderch (c. 1325) and the Red Book of Hergest (c. 1400). For centuries, the identity of the author of these stories has remained a mystery, with most scholars assuming it was a man, possibly a monk from North Wales. However, some years ago, a new theory proposed by Dr. Andrew Breeze sparked considerable interest and debate in the field of medieval Welsh literature. Dr. Breeze argued that the author of the Four Branches of the Mabinogi—the core tales of the Mabinogion—was none other than Gwenllian, a 12th-century Welsh princess who died fighting the Normans.
The Princess and the Tales
Princess Gwenllian, daughter of Gruffudd ap Cynan, King of Gwynedd, lived during a tumultuous period in Welsh history. Probably born in at the beginning of the twelfth century Gwenllian was raised at the Royal Llys at Gwynedd where her father was King Gruffydd ap Cynan and her mother Angharad. Beautiful but headstrong she fell in love with Gruffydd ap Rhys, a landless prince from South Wales with whom she eloped and married. Gwenllian was known for her courage and leadership, particularly during the battle of Kidwelly in 1136, where she led an army against the Normans and met a tragic end. But could this warrior princess also have been the author of one of Wales' most revered literary works?
Dr. Breeze’s hypothesis is based on a close analysis of the Four Branches of the Mabinogi, which include "Pwyll Prince of Dyfed," "Branwen Daughter of Llŷr," "Manawydan Son of Llŷr," and "Math Son of Mathonwy." These tales are rich with themes of leadership, heroism, and the supernatural, but they also delve into topics such as child-rearing, motherhood, and the domestic sphere—areas where a woman’s perspective might be more naturally attuned. Also Breeze points out that the Four Branches indicate understanding of both Gwynedd and Dyfed, both of which Gwenllian knew well. The princess was brought up in Gwynedd and lived most of her married life in Dyfed: she was familiar with diplomacy, governing a kingdom and understanding the vulnerabilities of kingship.
Feminine Perspectives in the Mabinogi
One of the key arguments in favour of Gwenllian’s authorship is the prominence of female characters and the detailed treatment of issues related to women in the Four Branches. Characters like Rhiannon and Branwen, who display strength, intelligence, and resilience, are central to the narratives. The tales explore complex themes such as childbirth, childlessness, and the rearing of children, which Dr. Breeze argues are unlikely to have been the primary concerns of any male writer. It has previously been suggested that the stories may well have been written by a monk
Dr. Breeze also points out that the stories often portray women as the ones who rescue or guide men, reversing the traditional roles seen in much medieval literature. This, he suggests, could indicate a female author who was deeply familiar with the roles and challenges faced by women in medieval Welsh society.
A Contested Theory
Despite the intriguing nature of Dr. Breeze's arguments, his theory has not been universally accepted. Some scholars, like Dr. Sioned Davies of Cardiff University, remain openminded, noting that the evidence for Gwenllian’s authorship is circumstantial at best. The fact that many medieval texts are anonymous and that authorship was often not a primary concern in that era makes definitive claims difficult.
Others argue that the focus on feminine themes does not necessarily point to a female author. Iestyn Daniel of the University of Wales suggests that a male author, possibly a monk, could have written the tales, especially if he had experience dealing with the spiritual and domestic concerns of women.
The Legacy of Gwenllian
Whether or not Gwenllian was the author of the Mabinogion, the discussion around her potential role has renewed interest in this remarkable figure from Welsh history. Her legacy as a warrior princess who fought and died for her people is already well-established, but if she was also the author of the Mabinogi, her contributions to Welsh culture would be even more profound.
Dr. Breeze’s theory, while controversial, has opened up new avenues for exploring the origins of the Mabinogion and has challenged long-held assumptions about the authorship of these tales. As with many historical debates, the truth may never be fully known, but the possibility that Gwenllian penned these iconic stories adds a new layer of depth to both her legacy and the stories themselves.
In the end, whether Gwenllian was the author or not, the Mabinogion is part of the rich cultural heritage of Wales, and the ongoing debate only serves to deepen our appreciation of these timeless tales.